Boasting stunning sunset vistas second only to Mallory Square and a convenient location for cruising to Key West attractions, this four-bedroom home offers a private slice of paradise on Stock Island. This prime bayfront property showcases bespoke features, including a 40-foot dock, sun deck, and custom-built tiki lounge with a built-in TV and outdoor kitchen. Protected by a security wall along one side, the private covered porch features a swing and furniture for breezy outdoor living. Two kayaks and two paddle boards are provided for exploring the island by water, and a convenient outdoor shower is available for rinsing off sand and saltwater. Or, bring your own boat and dock it right at your vacation home! The bright interior is well-appointed with stylish coastal design and updated amenities equipped for modern comfort. Plan meals easily in the stainless steel full kitchen, including a dishwasher for stress-free cleanup. A separate dry bar has a beverage fridge, a Keurig, and a traditional drip coffee maker for flexible morning brew options. Gather for memorable meals at the dining table. A dedicated home study offers a private space for remote work or a quiet writer's studio. It also features a Murphy bed, providing an additional sleeping option. After the day's adventures, unwind in the living room with shows and movies on the smart TV. Mounted air-conditioners throughout the house, free WiFi, and a washer/dryer combo round out the everyday essentials. While your focus may be on Key West, don't let the pleasures of Stock Island pass you by! The nearby Perry Hotel offers free public amenities, including the use of an on-site pool and access to a restaurant with daily live entertainment. The island is home to a ton of other great local dining options, and sight-seeing opportunities including the Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden. Things to Know Check-in time: 4:00 p.m. Check-out time: 10:00 a.m. All guests shall abide by the good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m. No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises. This property is managed by Seven Keys Vacations by Casago.
Location
Reviews5(14)
5
COULDN'T BE BETTER
This exceeded our expectations in every way. The location was beautiful and convenient. The beds were comfy. Everything worked. The golf cart was a lifesaver - I won't vacation without one in the future. All of the host recommendations were amazing. We will ABSOLUTELY be back.
Kaciana
-
5
Trip with Friends
We always have a great time here. This is our 3rd time to come down and will be back next year for our 4th time. We enjoy the great accommodations , the beds are very comfortable. Plenty of room for everyone to enjoy their time here. There is a boat dock to pull your boat up to with ease. There is a local city marina close by ,where we put our boat in and drive over to the boat dock. We also enjoy the back yard sitting area with a out door sink and grill with plenty of seating. The sunsets are the best view in the evenings. And this place is less than 10 min from the airport and Duval street. If we have anything that we need answer to the owner are always available to get in touch with and handle things promptly . You will love this place.. book the trip!
Melissa
-
5
Fantastic
Cannot say enough about this rental. It is an overall experience and leaves you wanting for nothing. The unit is well appointed, spacious and checks off all boxes for a wonderful vacation in Key West. The views are spectacular and the sunsets are to die for. Exceeds any expectations and the fact that it was large enough to accommodate our entire family was priceless. 10 out of 10 for sure.
Chris
-
5
Fantastic
Cannot say enough about this rental. It is an overall experience and leaves you wanting for nothing. The unit is well appointed, spacious and checks off all boxes for a wonderful vacation in Key West. The views are spectacular and the sunsets are to die for. Exceeds any expectations and the fact that it was large enough to accommodate our entire family was priceless. 10 out of 10 for sure.
Chris H.
-
5
A Home Away from Home-Highly Recommend
We thoroughly enjoyed our time at Sunset Bay in Key West during the singer-songwriter festival. Overall, our stay was excellent. We found the home to be very clean and well-maintained, and it appeared to have been recently updated, which was a pleasant surprise. We particularly appreciated how quiet the property was, allowing for restful nights after enjoying the festival events. And the sunsets were the best we’ve seen in key west! Thank you for providing such a wonderful accommodation for our visit.
Best regards,
Al & Courtney
Al and Courtney
-
5
Great location!
We had a great time. House was close to everything. From boat location to down town Duval street. We used the boat dock every day. City boat dock really close to put boat in. The house had everything we needed. Everything was clean. Great sunset views ! Great seating outside and hanging on out. We we definitely be returning.
Melissa A.
-
5
Amazing sunsets
This house is super close to the airport and all the happenings of Downtown Key West. The dock is a beautiful spot to enjoy the ever changing sunsets!
Gina J.
-
5
The Most Amazing Home, Sunsets, And Location!
My family and I recently had the pleasure of staying at Sunset Harbor, and it was nothing short of magical. This secret hideaway is a gem, offering breathtaking views right on the water. We were captivated by the most beautiful sunsets imaginable, viewed perfectly from the dock.
The location is ideal—a quick golf cart ride took us to downtown Key West, where we enjoyed a variety of restaurants and attractions. Stock Island itself has so much to offer, including pools, restaurants, a marina, and a gym, all within easy reach.
The week we spent at Sunset Harbor was unforgettable. My wife, son, and I found it to be our new favorite spot in the Key West and Stock Island area. We wholeheartedly recommend this incredible vacation rental to anyone looking for a memorable and enchanting getaway
The hosts were so amazing and accommodating! Everything we could possibly need was there and the house was perfect!
Blake S.
-
5
Sunset Bay is AWESOME and A great host
First off, Sunset Bay says it all. We enjoyed several beautiful sunsets either sitting on the dock or in the tiki hut. The interior is awesome and beautifully decorated. 2 great king size suites and more sleeping accommodations and two additional rooms. The tiki hut is furnished with a bar, TV, and awesome sound system - we spent several hours there each day. There is a lot to offer other than Duvall St, and here gave us the chance to explore both Key West and Stock Island. The owner, Andrew, was awesome. He was available for any questions and was incredibly thorough with instructions before arriving. We have already reached out and are coming back before the end of the year. Six stars for Sunset Bay!!
Steve T.
-
5
Perfect stay.
This place truly has everything one could want. I love that it truly feels like it’s own little resort with the tiki hut and outdoor kitchen area. Will be back!
Jake H.
-
5
Wonderful house for a vacation!
Loved the very large kitchen table for all the family to gather around for meals. Loved the large couch for movie night. Loved the waterfront tiki hut for relaxing during days and night. Close to a pool and plenty of dining. It was a great place!
John G.
-
5
Wintertime Escape
We traveled from the frozen tundra to a tropical paradise. It was almost 80 degrees warmer than home. A welcome change for January. First of all, and most importantly for us, everything was clean. The house was great with lots of new amenities, and the tiki bar was awesome. We were just a stone's throw from great food, drinks and live music. Hogfish Bar was one of our favorites. Food was outstanding and their margaritas were even better. Sunset Bay . . . A perfect place to do nothing or everything.
Bobby V.
-
5
Amazing Property
Couldn't ask for anything better than this property. The location is amazing. We were thinking about staying a block from Duval St and I'm so glad we didn't. We wouldn't have had the dock and water front and it makes this location the place to be. Only an 8 minute golf cart ride away to Duval plus the views. Also, loved that we didn't have to walk up and down a ton of stairs to the house, dock and back yard. Will rent this place every time we come!
Melissa T.
-
5
Perfect Home on Stock Island!
We had an amazing time staying at Sunset Bay. The home was perfect for our group of 5 couples. There was plenty of space for everyone to be comfortable. The tiki bar and dock were great places for our whole group to be able to hang out together for morning coffee and cocktail hour. Kayaks and paddle boards were an additional bonus to be able to use right off the dock. House was clean and had a well stocked kitchen with lots of essentials. We loved the location as it was only a short golf cart ride away from downtown Key West - easy to get to so many places. The owners shared a lot of great recommendations for restaurants, excursions and Key West spots to check out. We loved our stay and hope to be able to return again someday soon!
Kristin F.
-
Swipe for More Reviews
Have a question? Customer Questions & Answers
Want to know specifics? Ask anything about this specific property that you would like to know...
Request More Info
Check Availability
Arrival
Departure
Available
Unavailable
Check-In
Check-Out
Nearest departure is
Worry-Free Booking!
Cancel by for a full refund.
Worry-Free Booking!
Book now with FREE Cancelation up to 30 days before arrival. Just let us know in writing 30+ days before your stay, and you’ll receive a full refund of rent and taxes.
If you cancel within 30 days of arrival, no refund will be made unless we are able to re-rent the property for the same price and time period. If the property is re-rented for a lesser price or time period, you will receive a refund for the difference. We will make every effort to re-rent the property at the full amount, but we will negotiate rental rates in an effort to get the property re-rented to get you the highest refund possible.
This exceeded our expectations in every way. The location was beautiful and convenient. The beds were comfy. Everything worked. The golf cart was a lifesaver - I won't vacation without one in the future. All of the host recommendations were amazing. We will ABSOLUTELY be back.
Kaciana
5
Trip with Friends
We always have a great time here. This is our 3rd time to come down and will be back next year for our 4th time. We enjoy the great accommodations , the beds are very comfortable. Plenty of room for everyone to enjoy their time here. There is a boat dock to pull your boat up to with ease. There is a local city marina close by ,where we put our boat in and drive over to the boat dock. We also enjoy the back yard sitting area with a out door sink and grill with plenty of seating. The sunsets are the best view in the evenings. And this place is less than 10 min from the airport and Duval street. If we have anything that we need answer to the owner are always available to get in touch with and handle things promptly . You will love this place.. book the trip!
Melissa
5
Fantastic
Cannot say enough about this rental. It is an overall experience and leaves you wanting for nothing. The unit is well appointed, spacious and checks off all boxes for a wonderful vacation in Key West. The views are spectacular and the sunsets are to die for. Exceeds any expectations and the fact that it was large enough to accommodate our entire family was priceless. 10 out of 10 for sure.
Chris
5
Fantastic
Cannot say enough about this rental. It is an overall experience and leaves you wanting for nothing. The unit is well appointed, spacious and checks off all boxes for a wonderful vacation in Key West. The views are spectacular and the sunsets are to die for. Exceeds any expectations and the fact that it was large enough to accommodate our entire family was priceless. 10 out of 10 for sure.
Chris H.
5
A Home Away from Home-Highly Recommend
We thoroughly enjoyed our time at Sunset Bay in Key West during the singer-songwriter festival. Overall, our stay was excellent. We found the home to be very clean and well-maintained, and it appeared to have been recently updated, which was a pleasant surprise. We particularly appreciated how quiet the property was, allowing for restful nights after enjoying the festival events. And the sunsets were the best we’ve seen in key west! Thank you for providing such a wonderful accommodation for our visit.
Best regards,
Al & Courtney
Al and Courtney
5
Great location!
We had a great time. House was close to everything. From boat location to down town Duval street. We used the boat dock every day. City boat dock really close to put boat in. The house had everything we needed. Everything was clean. Great sunset views ! Great seating outside and hanging on out. We we definitely be returning.
Melissa A.
5
Amazing sunsets
This house is super close to the airport and all the happenings of Downtown Key West. The dock is a beautiful spot to enjoy the ever changing sunsets!
Gina J.
5
The Most Amazing Home, Sunsets, And Location!
My family and I recently had the pleasure of staying at Sunset Harbor, and it was nothing short of magical. This secret hideaway is a gem, offering breathtaking views right on the water. We were captivated by the most beautiful sunsets imaginable, viewed perfectly from the dock.
The location is ideal—a quick golf cart ride took us to downtown Key West, where we enjoyed a variety of restaurants and attractions. Stock Island itself has so much to offer, including pools, restaurants, a marina, and a gym, all within easy reach.
The week we spent at Sunset Harbor was unforgettable. My wife, son, and I found it to be our new favorite spot in the Key West and Stock Island area. We wholeheartedly recommend this incredible vacation rental to anyone looking for a memorable and enchanting getaway
The hosts were so amazing and accommodating! Everything we could possibly need was there and the house was perfect!
Blake S.
5
Sunset Bay is AWESOME and A great host
First off, Sunset Bay says it all. We enjoyed several beautiful sunsets either sitting on the dock or in the tiki hut. The interior is awesome and beautifully decorated. 2 great king size suites and more sleeping accommodations and two additional rooms. The tiki hut is furnished with a bar, TV, and awesome sound system - we spent several hours there each day. There is a lot to offer other than Duvall St, and here gave us the chance to explore both Key West and Stock Island. The owner, Andrew, was awesome. He was available for any questions and was incredibly thorough with instructions before arriving. We have already reached out and are coming back before the end of the year. Six stars for Sunset Bay!!
Steve T.
5
Perfect stay.
This place truly has everything one could want. I love that it truly feels like it’s own little resort with the tiki hut and outdoor kitchen area. Will be back!
Jake H.
5
Wonderful house for a vacation!
Loved the very large kitchen table for all the family to gather around for meals. Loved the large couch for movie night. Loved the waterfront tiki hut for relaxing during days and night. Close to a pool and plenty of dining. It was a great place!
John G.
5
Wintertime Escape
We traveled from the frozen tundra to a tropical paradise. It was almost 80 degrees warmer than home. A welcome change for January. First of all, and most importantly for us, everything was clean. The house was great with lots of new amenities, and the tiki bar was awesome. We were just a stone's throw from great food, drinks and live music. Hogfish Bar was one of our favorites. Food was outstanding and their margaritas were even better. Sunset Bay . . . A perfect place to do nothing or everything.
Bobby V.
5
Amazing Property
Couldn't ask for anything better than this property. The location is amazing. We were thinking about staying a block from Duval St and I'm so glad we didn't. We wouldn't have had the dock and water front and it makes this location the place to be. Only an 8 minute golf cart ride away to Duval plus the views. Also, loved that we didn't have to walk up and down a ton of stairs to the house, dock and back yard. Will rent this place every time we come!
Melissa T.
5
Perfect Home on Stock Island!
We had an amazing time staying at Sunset Bay. The home was perfect for our group of 5 couples. There was plenty of space for everyone to be comfortable. The tiki bar and dock were great places for our whole group to be able to hang out together for morning coffee and cocktail hour. Kayaks and paddle boards were an additional bonus to be able to use right off the dock. House was clean and had a well stocked kitchen with lots of essentials. We loved the location as it was only a short golf cart ride away from downtown Key West - easy to get to so many places. The owners shared a lot of great recommendations for restaurants, excursions and Key West spots to check out. We loved our stay and hope to be able to return again someday soon!
Kristin F.
Worry-Free Booking! We offer FREE cancelation up until 30 days before arrival for new bookings.
Worry-Free Booking ✨
Book now with FREE Cancelation up to 30 days before arrival. Just let us know in writing 30+ days before your stay, and you’ll receive a full refund of rent and taxes.